We Offer A Professional And Client-Centric Approach To Serving The Needs Of Our Clients

Brandon, Kathryn and Michael Schwartz

Fair value vs. fair market value: Why it matters in buyouts

On Behalf of | Nov 11, 2026 | Firm News

When your business partnership reaches its end, the conversation between shareholders inevitably turns to the buyout. You may find yourself questioning how much your ownership stake is actually worth.

In Minnesota, two terms define this critical juncture: fair market value (FMV) and fair value. These terms sound interchangeable, but they can lead to very different outcomes in shareholder disputes and buyouts. Understanding which standard applies to your situation can help you position yourself for a fair and clean exit.

The real world price

The FMV is generally the concept most commonly associated with a sale. It refers to the price that a buyer would willingly pay an agreeable seller in an open market transaction. However, in the context of private companies, FMV is frequently subject to valuation discounts.

If you own a minority stake in a private company, your shares can be hard to sell because there is no active public market. You also have limited control over the company. Because of these limits, appraisers use two discounts: a discount for lack of control (DLOC) and a discount for lack of marketability (DLOM). Together, these discounts can cut your shares by 30% or more.

When courts assign a more equitable price

In Minnesota, courts often move away from FMV in favor of fair value. This is a legal standard intended to ensure equitable treatment for both majority and minority shareholders. 

In many buyout situations, especially those involving shareholder oppression or squeezeouts, Minnesota judges generally reject minority discounts. Under this approach, the law treats an ownership interest as a proportionate share of the company’s total value, rather than as an isolated, illiquid instrument that is difficult to sell.

Why strategy beats aggression

Managing a buyout requires an understanding which valuation standard applies to your specific situation. If you are a minority owner being forced out, your approach should focus on triggering a fair value standard to protect the full worth of your investment. Conversely, if you are the majority owner, you need to understand your exposure and how the court will view the fairness of your offer.

When knowledge is negotiating power

In business buyouts, the difference between FMV and fair value is often the defining factor in whether you receive full compensation for years of investment, risk and effort. Whether you are a minority shareholder or a majority owner, it is best not to leave this determination to chance. Consulting with experienced legal counsel can help you identify the right valuation method and build your strategy around it.